Tag Archives: women martial arts

Men Versus Women in the Martial Arts

The Differences Between Men and Women in the Martial Arts

I trained with women, way back in the 60s and 70s in the martial arts. Generally, they were smaller, and you had to be careful not to break their bones.

Still, they learned well, and, except for the occasional ball kicker, were better mannered.

how to get a black belt in on yearNow I see people like Rhonda Rousey, taking anybody and everybody to the mat and …snap!

And there are women teaching the martial arts all over the place. Some are good, some are bad. But that holds true for men.

There are differences, however.

The best way of describing these differences is through simple neutronic poetry: women are the nest and men are the spear.

Women have a tendency to gather people in and take care of them; men have a tendency to go out and bash heads.

And, this metaphor is so inadequate, yet, there is a truth within.

If you take a look at the yin yang expression of this: women internalize, men externalize. Which is like saying women cry and men yell. Yet, again, there is a truth within. Not for all, lots of anomalies and exceptions, but…the truth is still running deep within for most.

The most interesting thing for me, however, is the type of art sought by the genders.

Should men seek hard, arm bashing, skull knocking arts? Like Karate and kickboxing, and so on?

Should women seek force guiding, flowing arts? Like Tai Chi Chuan, Wing Chun, and so on?

It is an interesting question, and there are enough exceptions that this question will likely never be answered. (Though, in certain arts, it has been answered in the historical).

The fact of the matter is that the human being has choice, and while it would be nice to say that all thick bodies should wrestle, and all thin bodies should practice whippy Kung Fu, the truth is that the human being makes the choice, and adapts the body to the art.

Thus, though women perhaps should stick to quick, agile arts that guide, and men should keep running their heads into tree trunks, this all being an analysis of body types, the mind, and the spirit, will not accept such categorizations.

It is a wonderful world we live in. Strange…but wonderful.

This has been an article on women in the martial arts.

About the author: Al Case has provided a massive study of the martial arts in the five volume set, ‘Matrixing Karate,’ which can be found, with his other martial arts books, on Amazon. His website is MonsterMartialArts.com.

Women’s Karate Class: Should Ladies Learn Karate?

Here’s an interesting question I have never actually resolved. One would think that Ladies learning Karate, that a women’s Karate class would be a no brainer, but…call me a dinosaur, here’s my thoughts on the matter.
Women soften the class. Things tend to get softer, techniques are softer, punches are geared down.
There is the dating phenomena. Fault of the gals or not, the fact is that guys don’t always think through the head on their shoulders, and they are easily distracted.
You have to be careful where you hit them. Kick a guy in the apples and we take a deep breath and keep going. Hit gal in the chest and…OMG! Lawsuit, embarrassing moment, no way to alleviate it.
Girls shouldn’t fight. For that matter, guys shouldn’t fight. But girls shouldn’t fight.
If self defense is needed, there are other arts that should be studied that are more in keeping with a woman’s gentle personality, and which will preserve and even enhance that gentle personality.
And we could go on, but you see the considerations here, and these are just some of the simple ones. I have actually avoided some more hard core considerations (women hating men, etc.) because that risks stirring the fires just a little too much. I really just wanted to put forth a provocative ‘what if’ kind of a question, get some feedback, and not really offend anybody. To me, you see, Karate doesn’t have sexual organs, but the question is there for people with sexual organs. Interesting.
Anyway, my instructor used to hold a woman’s class. Didn’t let them learn with the men. And, an aside, he never taught that class. He always had a senior instructor teach that class. And that was his solution.
I don’t have a solution. I see problems aplenty with Ladies in Karate, and I have taught a Women’s Karate Class, but…well, you’re welcome to comment. And if you want to check out my courses, there is no sexual bias whatsoever at all, and they are at Monster Martial Arts.